Full disclosure, I only had a shake at Elie's, but, let me tell you about that shake. My daughter and I tried the chocolate peanut butter shake. It was fabulous. After a day at Fired Up Pottery, we had painted up an appetite. Being new to town we had been on the look out for places to replace our favorite go to ice cream places in Milwaukee. The owner of Fired Up Pottery recommended Elie's shakes. They were great. Thick, smooth, and flavorful. I can't speak to Elie's food, but we will be back for more shakes!