I've been coming here a couple times a year during the summer for the past twenty years.
The custard is good and nostalgic and the place itself is so cute. It's nice to walk along Monroe then get ice cream and hang out at the park.
The price for a sundae can be steep but the servings are large. Try to finish a small sundae by yourself and you may feel sick so I recommend sharing unless you're really having a craving.
The price for a pint is the same as a small, which is also pretty large, so sometimes I just get a pint and share that.
The custards themselves without any toppings are delicious too which says something.
It seems many people don't like the food but why would you get food at a custard shop?