We ordered take-out last Friday night. I ordered a gyro plate and my wife ordered a schwarma plate and we ordered a falafel plate to share. I am astounded by the 5 star reviews for this place and have to believe that either we just came on a bad night or everyone else has horrible taste.
I don't even know where to begin: The falafel was overfried; the rice was overcooked; the hummus was devoid of any flavor (reminded me of toothpaste); the schwarma looked and tasted like it was all of the burnt parts of the chicken that fell between the grill and landed in the oil catcher; the gyro was so oily and had an off flavor that i couldnt finish it.
Since Friday, we have been trying to remember a worse meal and I honestly can't think of one. I really wanted this place to taste better as it seems that Cafe Greco has closed and I wanted another option to Pita Jungle but I guess I deserve it for being lazy and not wanting to drive a few extra miles - i won't make that mistake again.