Oh no! What accessories can I wear with this orange and turquoise dress for the party tonight?
When you're faced with a similar question-- no doubt Hand Picked is the way to go.
No, it's not Tiffany, but it's not cheapie stuff like So Good (I think that's what it's called) or Claire's. It's a few steps up-- and more adult. I needed some silver ball-shaped earrings to go with a necklace I already had, but didn't feel like spending $150+ for the Tiffany ones. Hand Picked had a nice compromise. Ones for about $15, that no, weren't as heavy and shiny, but for the price? Heck yes!
Along with finding just about anything you could ever imagine at reasonable prices, the store employees here are super sweet and helpful when you're in need of assistance.