Atmosphere - Someone said this below, and I totally agree: I make the trek east to Pickle Bill's about once a summer, usually after a day at Mentor Headlands or the beach in Fairport Harbor, when I want to feel like I'm on vacation without leaving home. Pickle Bill's sits right on the water complete with floating bar and plentiful outdoor seating. The decor is crazy, for lack of a better word. Come here with an open mind! I never feel out of place with just a bathing suit and cover up on, PB's is very casual.
Food - I don't know remember how the prices are, but the food is GREAT! The warm fried dough with cinnamon butter is amazing. I always get the snow crab legs and they are always good. Everyone else I've eaten with has been happy with their food as well.
Overall, this is a fun, quirky seafood restaurant that should be a summer-staple if you live in the Cleveland area. Expect a wait for dinner on weekends.