Probably my favorite ice cream in Cleveland, by a hair though. Love the variety of flavors and seasonals. Best of all though, I love the ice cream cakes. YUMMMM. Staff is always great and somehow I always manage to escape the huge lines that always form.
Pro tip 1: you can order custom cakes (any ice cream you want) for pick up and depending on the day, they might be made fresh!
Pro tip 2: if you/your friends don't mind sharing, getting a prepacked pint or quart is a really good deal. They even throw in a few sugar or cake cones for free!