I have ordered poached salmon sides from Pisces in the past. I have always been pleased. I ordered a side for New Years, specifically organic Atlantic salmon. Well they muddled the order and after a 15 minute wait they gave me whatever they could find, in this case, generic Atlantic salmon. Not the same, but I was stuck. The sales guy told there was no difference in flavour and the only difference was what the fish fed on.
Well that's precisely why they should taste different. The generic salmon was fishy tasting and a disappointment. Not sure I will be back. Admit you made a mistake and don't fob off the customer with bs. If you do order from them call a day ahead and confirm your order with them.