If you are a fan of treating people with respect, I suggest you not patronize the Bicycle Cafe.
I attended Bicycle Cafe for the first time because I had been invited to a fundraiser featuring an evening of live music. There were service issues before the music started (I ordered the same draft beer as a friend and was charged a different price), but it was the attitude of the staff towards the musicians that ensures I will not be returning (and why I feel compelled to post).
During the last musician (a local artist named Didi Okobi) the bartenders turned up the jukebox multiple times. Perhaps the first time was an accident, but they continued to do it during the performance (four times), and laugh and jeer with patrons at the bar when requested to keep the music off until after the set. I was horrified that a place sponsoring live music would be so disrespectful to someone performing, and the audience, their customers, who were there to listen and enjoy.
I will not be returning to the Bicycle Cafe. If you are a fan of live music, or basic manners, I encourage you to avoid it as well. If you are a Pittsburgh musician, I encourage you to refuse to play this venue.