While typically pricier than the meat section at Harris Teeter, the meat is considerably better than Harris Teeter's. I've stopped into New York Butcher Shoppe only twice; the first time to browse and find out if they carry any sort of blood sausage (no dice, unfortunately) and the second time to purchase a wonderful beef tenderloin.
In addition to standard meat fare, the fridges also carry more interesting items like elk and rabbit. Definitely good to know. I've yet to try any of the pre-packaged items, but I'm sure that I will at some point. Even through the wrappers they all look delicious.
New York Butcher Shoppe is definitely a great addition to the area, though I wish it were a local shop rather than a chain.