At a risk of losing my Cincinnati-Cred, I'm about to announce that my spouse, 3+decades, born-and-raised Cincinnati (and I) agree:
Mitchell's Ice Cream is better than Greater's.
Alright, so don't hate. It actually is just different. It's flavorful and fun - there are many options at Mitchell's and they seem to always have many new experimental flavors when we go. Also, Mitchell's is a CLE shop with local pride, so I don't think they'll be taking over Cincinnati.
Sorbet: both flavors are great.
Ice Cream: Great Lakes beer-fusion ice cream is surprisingly amazing.
Service: attentive and focused.
Outside seating is great and there's plenty of space inside. I mean, it's Cleveland...so you gotta have indoor seating with that weather.
Let me know if you try Mitchell's, Cincinnati. Tell me if you agree with David & Sarah C.