As suggested, I went back to try more of the menu. Still 3 stars.
The place was empty near closing time on a Saturday night, much unlike some of the other nearby restaurants. Bad sign.
The soup was excellent and exactly as I remembered it from the first visit.
Lemongrass chicken was a juicy grilled whole boneless thigh that was simply perfect. That's it for the good.
"Beef" satay skewers were overcooked and were either of some of the worst beef I've ever had or were from some related roadkill variety. Sauce was the same watery thing from the last time. Volcano chicken skewers were pre-cooked fried chicken pieces covered in an incredibly spicy sauce; not pleasant.
Unfortunately, it seems as though there isn't the turnover here for all things on the menu to be prepared fresh or from top ingredients. Avoid side skewers, which come with any and all combination deals. Service is also sub-par, difficult to get a server's attention even with being the only table.