Scaddabush is a solid option if you can't decide on a place to go. They're located at East Beaver Creek among all the other eateries so parking will be a hassle if you're coming at prime time (try coming at 7ish).
We ordered they're naked mozzarella for an app. which has been raved about by others and we found those people to be right. It came with the mozzarella of course, pieces of bread, and a side of garlic and spicy jam. One mistake we made was by putting too much garlic, it'll overpower everything and you won't be able to enjoy it! Thankfully we only ruined a small portion of the moz. Definitely recommend it if you're getting an appetizer.
We also ordered the pesto fettuccine and the butcher pizza. Both were delicious and I can't complain about them. Service was extremely friendly and the waitresses took good care of us.
Be sure to look out for coupons you get in the mail as this is the reason we decided to make our first visit here, and it probably won't be our last!