Can't give it 5 stars because I've had a couple poor service experiences here (of 100+ times dining), but PJ is one of my very favorite local restaurants. Can be crowded, at which point the level of service will go down...as with pretty much all awesome, affordable restaurants? Don't know why people would put "crowded" as such a downside. Other people want to eat here too. Call in your order, you goons.
Super casual atmosphere compared with a lot of Arcadia-area business lunch type places, but the food is absolutely top notch.
The quality of the meals here is almost unparalleled for the price. My favorites are mahi-mahi with pita chips, hummus trio with chicken, lentil fetoosh salad, and the lavosh shwarma wrap. I substitute veggies on some of these and they always get it right.
Also possibly the best iced tea in town. And they always give me a to-go cup.