I'd give it 5 stars but for a few little glitches. Service was outstanding & the food was nearly perfect but for a few inconsistencies- too few broccoli in 1 soup & too much in another. There were unopened clams & tons of celery in the clams. Besides that we loved the tots and the bone marrow. I've had marrow many times, including in France, and this was my favorite preparation. Luscious! Other favorites were the burgers, brisket, and steak. I loved the salad too. The beer list was exceptional but they only had 6 wines by the glass. All the desserts were wonderful. Favorites were the Elvis & the chocolate cake. We can't wait to go back again.