I have a pretty serious crush on this mom and pop pizza shop.
Thin yet chewy, toppings to the very end of the pie and above-cheese, crispy pepperoni. They have pasta, wings and salads, too, and for only $4 you can get one of the largest side caesar salads in all of TO. Hail Caesar.
I have only had delivery (35 minutes, debit at the door), so I really can't speak to the ambiance, but if this joint is half as pretty as their pies are tasty, it'd be worth checking out in person.