This review is based on both the atmosphere and the food. I have been going to this bar for the last ten years and have a lot of great memories here. With the addition of the rooftop, it is spacious enough that it usually is not too jam packed. However, some nights it being crowded is what makes it so fun. It is the best place in the city to watch a penguins game. Playoff games here are amazing.
In terms of the food, it is better than you would expect for s place like this that is more of a bar than place to eat. My usual go to is the buffalo chicken hoagie or the wings. They also have some great house made ranch. If my review were based only on food it would probably be a 3, but everything else this place offers bumps it up.