I LOVE Tuck Shop - everything is outstanding from the ambiance, to the food, to the service. It's a bit challenging to find as there isn't any super conspicuous signage, but I kind of appreciate that low-key vibe.
I have enjoyed the toast with creamy garlic, zuchinni spears, mac n' cheese (sans bacon), and the grilled romaine salad. Super good spot to take a first date, FYI.