We came in with no reservation and I was on the fence about coming here. I will say that it wasn't a very warm welcome when I called on my way and got there asking about a table. I didn't know the drill about grabbing a bar table. But, once we got settled, this was a trip back in time that was well worth it. Traditional steakhouse finds. A pretty limited menu. But, the steaks are the showstopper centerpiece here. One of the best I have had! We both loved our steaks and after one of the hip new restaurants in town the night before this was a fun contrast. It is pretty pricey for how straightforward the menu is and how old-school the decor is, so not sure I would head back in a hurry with all the new dining Madison has to offer. But a gem that hopefully will stick around for a long time.