Great Idea, Terrible Execution
First of all I'd like to emphasize that the name and concept for this restaurant is great. Being a fan of Mario, I was excited. The reality hit when I finally tried the restaurant for myself.
The pizza was bland, the sauce tasted like it was from a can. We would have had a better experience if we had picked up our own take-and-bake pizza from the local supermarket and made it at home. The theming was inconsistent. I couldn't decide if it was celebrating classic Nintendo or Captain America. It looked like random objects from a teenager's bedroom were strewn about.
I'm surprised at the other reviews because they nowhere near reflected the type of experience I had. I have serious doubts whether my pizza was made with fresh ingredients since the sauce was bland and tasted like it had been left out all night.
This establishment is brand new, so there is room to improve, but they need to have consistent theming and higher quality ingredients.