I was unimpressed when I went. The texture of the ice cream was so-so, with a lot of crystals that made it feel grainy. It wasn't all that creamy. The vanilla was way too sweet for my liking, and the caramel wasn't intense enough. It's good, but not fantastic. Given the prices, I would expect fantastic. I think the interior is lovely (especially compared to Oh Yeah), but I'm concerned that there seems to be more focus on that part of the business than the desserts. Either way, it's a lovely, albeit pricey, post-dinner treat after visiting Noodlehead. It's just not the best on offer in the area.