The throwback sign and interior are cute. They were pretty busy so sitting inside would've been noisy and not relaxing. They tried to help everyone but were not big on smiling. With time I'm hopeful they'll be more efficient and warm. They weren't unfriendly, but maybe a tad overwhelmed?
My husband felt it was expensive and griped about it. A few bites in he said "This IS really good ice cream".
Tad confused about a sign saying they served a sandwich. Do they? Doesn't seem like a natural fit or that they're set up for it but...who knows?
If we were in the area and craving ice cream, we might come back. We might also choose to sit at one of the nearby restaurants and order a desert for a few dollars more.