This place gets 3 stars for atmosphere and the benefit of the doubt for still being pretty new (although the owner has years of experience in the restaurant industry, so i'm not sure if the pity is warranted). I'll probably try it again in a few months, but if the quality is the same, then i wont come back.
The drink selection is weak -- pretty much just Molson products for beer. I asked for the hopiest beer they had on tap and got something super pale that tasted flat. I didn't order a second. Maybe i'm being picky, but in Toronto i've come to expect some variation in the beer selection -- one local option would be nice. My friends ordered the sangria and the mojito and both tasted watered down.
Food was definitely sub-par. For starters, they we're sold-out of half the menu (which is fine), but what we tried was flavourless and cold. I was also a little annoyed that they had "Samplers" on their menu that offered one of every item in that section but offered $0 discount.
I will say that the service was really friendly. It was easy to tell that everyone there was still new but they we're really nice, and certainly put in the effort to do a good job.