5 stars, definitely.
We went to this beautiful place last Sunday for lunch. We were the first table (and I made the reservation). The waiter was very friendly and knowledgeable.
The first pea and oyster soup was not on the menu ( might be a new item they are trying). Excellent soup followed by crab cake as appetizer and tomato salad (the salad is not on the menu too).
We were almost full when the entree arrived. I ordered a medium rare New York strip which was cooked exactly as I wanted. However, I think they used the wrong cut because it is so dry. Anyhow, a glass of good Cab covered the wooden steak.
Surprisingly, we still had room for the wonderful mango cheesecake. It was beautiful plated and tasted great!
Even though the steak is not perfect, I still give them 5 stars. You know what was the best part: it only costs $20/person (excluding the drinks).