I also saw the same show two days ago. My buddy ponied up and bought the expensive seats for us in the dice pit ($115 total).
I'm not exactly sure what my expectations were based upon but I was just itching to hear all of the nursery rhymes. He saved them for the very last two minutes and only said five or six of them. The rest of the show was pretty geriatric. It seemed that the bulk of his jokes were about getting old. I'm not in my 60's so I didn't find his material to be all that hilarious.
I'd probably go back if the tickets were free but other wise I'd rather go see Carrot Top three times for the same price.