Went here for lunch on a Friday to meet an old friend that I studied abroad with in Latin America. I am fairly new to the Madison area and have been on a hunt for Latin American/Caribbean cuisine. We got there around 11:30 -- which was smart. I suggest arriving before 12:30 to avoid the huge lunch rush.
Overall, this place was outstanding. I got the Patacon Pisao Lunch and stuffed my sandwich with black beans, eggplant, and white cheese. It was to die for. I also upgraded to the Shrimp (Camaron) and Coconut Salad which I highly recommend. Top it all off with a Modelo, and you are set. The variety of imported beers available was a huge plus.
Why not 5 stars? A few reasons. One, it was a bit pricey. Based on the location and decor, I was expecting the prices to match. Two, the sandwich was hard to eat. I had to deconstruct the whole thing and eat it with a fork -- which is fine -- but I would have preferred to eat it the traditional way. Finally, the wait was a bit long (although well worth it).
Overall -- a must-visit. I will definitely be back.