First visit: came for dinner. We were not impressed with the atmosphere, but we came back for the food.
Second visit: came for breakfast on a Sunday. Blueberry pancakes were good and service was much improved.
Third/fourth visits: Happy Hour. This is one of longest and most inclusive happy hours in the area. $2-3 beers, $4 wines, and a good selection of small plates for under $5.
If you like good food and you're not in a hurry, Melissa's is a good spot.