If it weren't for two friends who absolutely love Gullifty's and swear by their desert, I would have only tried Gullifty's once.
It's not because Gullifty's is bad - the desert is fine - but I don't think it warrants the title of "Best Desert in Pittsburgh." Gullifty's is like an independent Eat N Park. Portions are plentiful, the atmosphere is comfortable, and the food is average. If that's what your'e looking for, this is the place to go.