Yesterday was my third time at this restaurant and it was great, I can't remember having a bad experience the first two times either. The first time I came was for my bachelorette party which was almost two years ago. We stopped here to eat and exchange gifts and then headed over to the casino. I can't recall exactly what dish or martini I had, but I remember thinking the martinis were delicious. The second time I came about a year and a half ago was for lunch with my colleagues. I remember getting a grilled cheese with french onion soup. I remember the soup was very good.
As for my visit yesterday I had wanted to try the coconut Mahi Mahi, but it was no longer on their menu although it is listed on their website. I got the garden grilled chicken instead and it was good - not fantastic - but had some flavor and was plentiful. It came with crostini bread which was ok - again not fantastic. I did not go for the martini this time because we were out for my birthday and I wanted some good ol' chocolate cake. My friend got the salted caramel martini and loved hers and I had the chocolate brulee mousse. My friend had a piece and said that it was "too much chocolate" but for a chocolate lover like me - it was divine! It came with a cherry glaze on the side and whipped cream - I ate everything!
The service was ok. Honestly there really isn't anything fantastic about this place but it's not horrible either - I would definitely come back again and again. As for pricing, I would say its moderate. The martinis are $10 which is steep but their filet mignon dish is under $20 which is reasonable.
I do appreciate that this restaurant is handicap accessible for my friend who uses a wheelchair. Also the atmosphere is such that you can have a casual get together with friends or a more romantic-casual date night. Also you just can't beat the energy of E. 4th street! I think next time I will be back to try their brunch - I hear they have mimosas!