We stopped in here about a half hour before they closed on Sunday night, so they were out of a few types of cookies (the white chocolate cookie particularly bummed me out). But, it was late so no biggie!
The lady behind the counter was very nice and friendly and asked us if we wanted to sample anything. We sampled a few before we decided.
I ordered one tuxedo cookie and one peanut butter with Medieval-something-or-other ice cream. The lady helping us said it was a new flavor and she hadn't sampled it but that it had caramel and chocolate swirled into vanilla ice cream. Sold.
After I paid, I actually looked at the menu and noticed that they had toppings like caramel and fudge sauce. I wish I would have noticed that... but I'll keep it in mind for next time.
The cookies were a bit hard, probably because it was late and they weren't as fresh... but they were still REALLY REALLY DELICIOUS, especially the peanut butter cookie. Also, Thrifty ice cream never disappoints and this new flavor was amazing.
Cookies are one of my favorite things on earth.. especially when home made, so this place is a HUGE winner in my book. I will definitely be back. I would also love to see them make some type of a salted caramel chocolate chip cookie (hinthint)!