The New Yorker is a cute place with great potential. I would really give this place a 2.5.
My friend ordered the French Toast - which was great! I ordered the Lox + Cream Cheese wrap, I didn't enjoy it but it was tolerable.
The service we experienced was quite awkward. We informed the waiter that we were waiting for a 3rd person. My friend eventually came and the waiter came almost instantly and expected us to order our food. The 3 of us had questions marks above our heads, but we quickly moved on from that.
At the end of the meal, the waiter just tossed our cheques in front me and stood there until we noticed he was waiting (we were in the middle of a conversation). I then noticed that my cheque was incorrect and when I mentioned that the price seemed off, he simply stated that all of the wraps were the same price. As we were leaving the store, I quickly checked the menu, and I was given the wrong price. Might just be an honest mistake, but with all the other little moments- it just validated the other reviews on Yelp regarding the poor service here.
2.5/5 because I would still like to come back to have the french toast, great location and we were warmly greeted when we entered the store.