This is most likely the best and only acceptable place for seafood in Madison. If you're used to great and fresh seafood this place will meet your standards. The oysters were great but were noticeably different from the fresh oysters I am accustomed to, but I craved them so much I ordered another half dozen. I had the fish and chips and it was the second best fish and chips I ever had. Also ordered the red snapper, which I would highly recommended, its one of the best options on the menu.