When I worked uptown, my buddy and I would occasionally venture down to the Cotswald Pizza Peel for the lunch buffet. I remember it being tasty with many beer selections. The family was craving pizza tonight so we thought it might be a good time to try the Matthews location.
Upon entering, I was really impressed with the interior. I could tell that they really invested in this new location. I was the saddened by the fact that they had no beers on special tonight. I am of the opinion that if "tap room" is in the title of your restaurant, you should have at least two beers on special every night.
When I received my over priced beer, it was good and our fried pickles app. came shortly after. The pickles were just okay. They tasted as if they had been frozen for a while and the breading was super thin. I immediately asked for another ranch dipping sauce as the container it came in was enough for about 6 pickles. It didn't matter in the end as we didn't finish all the pickles anyway. Wishful thinking I guess.
After my second over priced beer, our pizzas came. The table split a cheese and a godfather. Again, just okay. I want to highlight the great service and attentive manager who both made sure that our needs were met. I just can't give it higher than a 3 because of the above reasons.