I had a super great experience here. In fact this may become my go-to wine bar! I love the dual use of the space. On one side it's a bookstore appointed with stylish mid-century furniture. The other side is the restaurant/bar. This side is smaller and more cozy. They weren't able to seat me at a table since they were fully booked for the evening, but I found a spot at the bar. James, the bartender, was fantastic and super nice. Very warm and welcoming. He recommended a drink not on the menu and it was delish. If you want a great tasting cosmo, have him hook one up for you! He might even tell you his secret which I won't spill here. Casellula has a real chill relaxed vibe. The noise level is perfect and didn't interfere with conversation. Would say it's more for a mature crowd. The bartender mentioned that they have live music during the week and definitely want to check that out!
After for food I had the cod fish fritters and chèvre. You get three ample sized fritter balls. Great for sharing. This first visit set a high standard. I'm a fan!!