I'm giving this place a good review mainly based on service and atmosphere. We have been here twice to watch games which is what this place is perfect for. It's big enough that you don't feel bad taking up a table for a whole game and the servers are totally cool with you staying until the end of the game (we continue to buy drinks after we eat, so that probably helps).
The decor is really nice and it's a very comfortable restaurant. My concern is that it is SO big I'm not sure if they'll be able to stay in business because besides it being a really good place to watch a game, the food is just okay.
I've had the Orange and Brew Beef sandwich (just ok) and the Buffalo Chicken Wrap (good- I'll probably get this again). Both came with the crinkle cut fries that another reviewer wrote about (probably were frozen, but I enjoyed them). My husband had the pizza (just ok) and the BLT (just ok). So, out of the four things we've tried, we'd probably only order one of them again. Not great.
Regarding the beer selection- yeah, it's not that exciting, but I think the name "Orange and Brew" is more of a tribute to the Illini than it is a reference to their beer selection.
I would love to see this place re-vamp their menu to be a little more interesting and maybe not so big- maybe pick a theme? I think they're going to have trouble staying in business if they don't.