Went on a double date with another couple who also enjoy seafood. The service was pretty good. Their menu selection was also pretty good. I was hoping for more lobster options but it was only a single menu item of 1.5lbs lobster. So we ordered that and the shrimp, calamari, and cured fish plate. The food all in all was good. The lobster was okay. Not the best I've had nor the worst. Average pricing for this type of fare and good service gets the place 4 stars. A better lobster selection in the menu and/or a lobster with more meat on it would have earned the place five stars. I know this place is well known for oysters but we weren't there during the happy hour or late night, and I didn't feel like oysters so yeah. I am sure it's as good as what people say...