I know my pizza. I am at least an enthusiast, possibly even an expert - I practically lived at a friends pizza shop when I was a kid and worked in one for years before graduating - and I was broke enough to eat pizza everyday because it was free.
I say Greco's is the best pizza in town. Loaded with toppings - perfect sauce, perfect crust, and the specialty pizza's are solid. Its a bit of a drive for me but who cares.
Complaints about interior design (the word sexy is a pro and family is a con when attached to a pizza place? Seriously?...Seriously?!) are ridiculous. You want to be pretentious go to Bonterra's or Teatro's they have ok pizzas - but you won't enjoy yourself half as much and the pizza isn't half as good. Trust me, if you feel you need to impress with a sexy/modern pizza shop just get a new friend/girlfriend/wife instead and relax. Greco's has the right look for what it is.