So many haters. Snobs, snobs everywhere. In my 3 years in Madison I've been to this place almost every two weeks. Portions are huge, price is really great for the money. Service is good, and can be ridiculously fast when they're not busy.
My favorite dishes: rigatoni nino (cream sauce pasta with chicken and mushroom), penne pollo pesto (basil pesto sauce pasta with chicken), tutto pasta (tomato cream sauce pasta with chicken, mushroom and onion), veal scaloppine with marsala wine sauce (best thing ever).
Admittedly, I didn't really like real Italian food when I went to Europe, but I don't go here to eat 'authentic' food; I just go to eat delicious food that fills me up without draining my wallet.