It's still very new, so I'm willing to cut them some slack.
The menu looks amazing, but I haven't had the food actually live up to the descriptions once. I ordered the Po'boy, which looked amazing, and tasted more like a frozen fish stick in a sandwich. I could've gone next door to No Frills for the same effect.
As a nearby resident, I love the upgrade, compared to Sharkey's. The clientele is much better, and they've done a fantastic job with decor and service.