I've been to Nellie's twice now. The only two complaints I have are that the hostess is very rude. She has an attitude that is completely unnecessary. When we called for a reservation she said we didn't need one. We arrived 10 minutes later and she said we needed to have a reservation because there was a 30 minute wait. The catering manager, Jackie, saw that we were not happy and she seated us and let us know about the special appetizer and took our drink order. Had it not been for Jackie and her hospitality I would've given up on this place and given a completely bad review. Jackie is awesome! That hostess needs a different job...maybe in the kitchen away from the public.
Now for the food...the food is good but it's never hot. I understand cooking things to order takes longer but when it comes out it should be hot. My food was lukewarm at best. We ordered the apple pie at the end and they said that the skillet it comes in would be hot. The ice cream on top of it barely melted so it definitely was not hot. I'm not sure that I would recommend this place. The food is good, not great. The waitstaff seemed to be pushed to the max. They need more servers.
If you do go ask for Greg as your waiter and say hey to Jackie.