I'm a big fan of this place. The prices are fair, the cake selection is fantastic. They also have a large selection of actual meals - they are definitely not "just desserts". I got their bagel tuna melt and it was amazing.
I think it's a cozy place that is larger than it looks from the outside. The decor is a bit of a mish-mash but that doesn't matter to me. To me, the food is most important and this place is a winner.