Passed through here on a Tuesday evening on the second-to-last day of the year. We had just had a 6-hour drive up from New York and maybe we were tired, hungry, and cold, but this place hit the spot. We got the corner table next to the windows on the far right as you enter the place. They have hooks on virtually every post, which is something I wish more restaurants offered.
I can't speak to the whole menu, but the appetizers (chorizo and some kind of pork croquette) were both very good, especially the croquete. My steak and frites were very tasty. A reviewer below mentioned how the steak was ordered medium and it was closer to medium-rare. I'll agree with that part, but it was definitely not tasteless. It came with a plum(?) sauce and was spiced fine. In any event, it was fresh and I really enjoyed it. The rest of my table each enjoyed their meals -- silence and clean plates is usually a good indication.
Maybe there's a higher standard in Quebec for good food as I find it is more available up there than the prices we have to pay here in New York for the same quality, but I am surprised at the negative reviews below nonetheless. Old Montreal is my favorite part of the area and I'm sure there are plenty of good places to eat, but this is definitely one of them.