Black Sheep is a complete opposite of your local suburban eatery. Cute but may be in the wrong location.
When you think American "small plate" appetizer, you're probably thinking decent size portion. Black Sheep delivers great tasting and great presentation, but under delivers with portions for the location. I wouldn't question the portions if this were on the Las Vegas Blvd. It just doesn't make sense for a suburban area.
The Lost Word...The Last Word cocktail was great as it was refreshing and evenly balanced with the food ordered.
The dessert was Tres Leches and Brownie. Similar to the apps, the presentation was beautiful, but nothing about the two were a wow factor. Truthfully, it tasted like an average brownie and tres Leches cake plated with beautiful garnishes.
Overall, the 5 stars are for service and execution. Everything about what Black Sheep offers is great, I feel however it doesn't cater to the area it's in.