| rev:text
| - Great perogies!
Seriously, Butler's Pantry offers a $5 for 3 perogies that is a delicious daily special you should take advantage of if you're down Roncy way. They're a bit... odd, but tasty nonetheless: spinach and feta filled, with a side of thick sour cream and a small pile of caramelized onions with a touch of cumin. I was incredulous, but damned if I wasn't pleasantly surprised.
Unfortunately, my sandwich was a bit subpar -- the bread was toasted and had a 40 grit sandpapery "I will destroy the roof of your mouth" texture to it that just isn't cool. I'm sure most readers are familiar with what I'm describing here. Regardless, it kinda hurt to eat. The fillings -- veggies all -- were nice enough, but a bit mushy and sparse.
The rest of the menu was confusing. As others have noted, they have what can kindly be called an "eclectic" menu; some might refer to it as "unfocused", "scattershot", or "hit and miss". It struck me as though the house put together a list of things they enjoyed eating and/or cooking and figured it would be great.
I'm sure some of the dishes are good. I'm equally sure some aren't, and judging by the very mixed reviews here I sincerely think they need to do some revision. I hope they do, 'cuz those perogies are fiiiiiine. There's some skill in that there kitchen, it just needs a bit more focus.
Outside of the food, I found the service good, very friendly and helpful, though a bit overwhelmed (one girl for the whole place); layout is your typical diner, though split into two rooms, which makes the poor server's job that much tougher. She does admirably all things considered.
Final note: it apparently has poor airflow (judging by a conversation overheard between server and regular patron). That's why it was very cold there while I ate. They had a door open. If they close the door, it's very hot. Diners should bear this in mind.
Let's say 4 star for the perogies and service, 2 for the sandwich and chill, for an average score of 3. I'm sure I'll return, though I won't be in a rush unless I'm craving the perogies!
|