I really love it here. The pizza is seriously delicious which has been consistent on these reviews but an important thing to note is the staff has had serious improvements in the past year or so. So the other reviews may have been old or just during one of their super busy moments - from personal experience I know Saturday nights are crazy there!
On Sunday, I go during the evenings and sit at the bar. They always have football on during the season and the bartender for Sunday evening shifts is great. He is attentive and has an awesome personality (even if I pick on his Seahawks jersey.. Which I do only because I'm a bitter niners fan)
I recommend strongly for good atmosphere and food! Enjoy :)