Overall, it was a disappointing experience.
When visiting Toronto, it's fun and exciting to try something new. It doesn't always work out.
I'll get this out of the way...the smoked meat is fantastic. Everything else...was not. The salami was dry. The matzoh ball soup was like two pieces of bread floating in slightly yellow water (no flavor whatsoever). I asked my friend what she ordered so I could reference it and she said, "I can't remember. Please don't make me think about it again".
Our table had been wiped, but only directly in front of the seats. The middle of the table had crumbs and debris. The condiment dispensers had caked on dried mustard that looked like it had been there for a week. The floor was filthy and got worse the further under the table you looked (clearly the staff has been trained to simply spot sweep...shouldn't it be getting done thoroughly at least once a day).
There are better delis and there are probably better options within a two block radius. Take the walk.