I came here a few months ago and I have no idea why I'm just now writing a review.
After hiking up "A" Mountain, a few of my friends and I were craving ice cream and walked on over to SOTC. After looking at their selection (and making my friend try their raspberry jalapeno ice cream), I got my default combo, cake batter, brownies, and kit kat. The service was good, price was expected, and the ice cream was ok. It wasn't quite on par with cold stone, but if I was on Mill and wanted ice cream I'd probably stop by again.