I'm sorry, but I'm not a believer in the church of Geraci's pizza.
I've tried cheese pizza. And mushroom pizza. And white pizza. And most recently, a margherita pizza. They were ok...but nothing I'd go out of my way for. My pizza was actually overdone (hello, blackened crust) the past time I was there and despite having fresh basil and seemingly fresh tomatoes, it wasn't all that flavorful.
What do I like about Geraci's? The pasta I've tried is pretty good - especially the spinach ravioli in a tomato cream sauce. Service is always good, too, with the bus boys almost being too attentive. One time I heard one of the servers going out of his way to make accommodations for a guest requesting gluten free pasta, and that made me happy. Servers are also very knowledgeable about what is suitable for a vegetarian like me and what isn't, and that's a welcome change from having to wait while someone runs back into the kitchen to ask a question.
I wish I loved Geraci's pizza as much as everyone else does. But since I don't, my quest for the best pizza in CLE continues.