I'd eaten Falbo's since college in the '90s, but I hadn't had it in years. "Let's give it a shot," I told my husband, and we got a hand-tossed pepperoni and picked it up ourselves.
It was just as I remembered. The cheese was stretchy and generous, the sauce was slightly sweet, and the pepperoni was greasy in that amazing pepperoni way. Hands down, this is STILL my favorite pizza in Madison.