Two things: when you come here, bring cash. And come hungry.
If they didn't only take cash, they'd have 5 stars from me. But as it stands, the food and drinks make it well worth the effort to find on-street parking in this trendy and slightly-annoying-to-drive-in neighborhood (yeah, I'm a snob about private lots--nobody's perfect!).
Order the fresh-blended Bloody Mary with a bison burger. They've also got some INCREDIBLE vegetarian choices.
This is by far my favorite restaurant in the Atwood area (and there are a few that are runners-up to each other, but none that compare to Alchemy). Stop in after an evening class at the Midwest Clay Project or Ford's Gym. :)