Have been looking for really good pizza in Durham since I moved here a few years back. Have tried them all in Pickering and Ajax and everything has been just okay (Except Il Fornello which is really good Neapolitan style pizza).
Decided to try places in Whitby and found this via a Google search (4.9 stars). The pizza here is amazing! It's a classic New York City style slice; not to thick or thin with the right amount of droop at the tip.
Also ordered a pound of wings which were very tasty but fatty and not crispy enough as they cook them in the oven instead of a deep fryer. I'd do the wings again but would ask them to cook them longer.
The place is small with no tables but they do have a counter with stools if you're looking to stop by for a slice. Their business is mostly take out and delivery.
If you're looking for a classic Italian pizza joint with really great pizza and friendly service, this is the place.